FOR IMMEDIATE
NEWS RELEASE
NEWS RELEASE
# 013
FROM: CLERK
OF SUPREME COURT OF LOUISIANA
On the
13th day of February, 1998 , the following
action was taken by the Supreme Court of Louisiana
in the case(s) listed below:
REHEARING
GRANTED; THE ORDER OF 2/12/98 IS RECALLED; THE STATE'S
WRIT APPLICATION IS DENIED :
98-KK- 0386
STATE OF LOUISIANA v. CURTIS LEE KYLES (Parish of
Orleans)
MARCUS, J.
- not on panel.
TRAYLOR, J.
- would deny the rehearing.
On the 18th
day of February, 1998 ,
the following action was taken by the Supreme Court
of Louisiana in the case(s) listed below:
WRIT
GRANTED WITH ORDER :
98-KK- 0369
STATE OF LOUISIANA v. ANTHONY DIEZ (Parish of Jefferson)
KIMBALL, J.
- not on panel.
TRAYLOR, J.
- dissents from bond reduction.
KNOLL, J. -
dissents from bond reduction.
STAYS
DENIED; WRITS DENIED:
98-CC- 0380
KENNETH G. HEBERT, ET AL v. KRAFT USA, ET AL (Parish
of Lafayette)
TRAYLOR, J.
- not on panel.
98-CC- 0387
CORDELIA JOHNSON, ET AL v. DIXIE BUILDING MATERIALS,
INC., ET AL (Parish of Orleans)
MARCUS, J.
- votes to grant.
VICTORY, J.
- not on panel.
KNOLL, J. -
votes to grant.
98-CC- 0397
ROLLINS CAB SERVICE INC., ET AL v. CITY OF NEW ORLEANS
DEPARTMENT OF UTILITIES, ET AL (Parish of Orleans)
KIMBALL, J.
- votes to grant.
JOHNSON, J.
- not on panel.
TRAYLOR, J.
- votes to grant.
WRITS
DENIED :
97-KK- 2852
STATE OF LOUISIANA v. HENRY STAN (Parish of Orleans)
KIMBALL, J.
- not on panel.
TRAYLOR, J.
- would grant the writ.
KNOLL, J. -
would grant the writ.
98-CC- 0034
BELINDA GAIL FRANKLIN, ET AL v. GEORGE DEWEY, ET AL
(Parish of Calcasieu)
MARCUS, J.
- not on panel.
On the 19th
day of February, 1998 , the following
action was taken by the Supreme Court of Louisiana
in the case(s) listed below:
WRIT
GRANTED WITH ORDER:
98-CD-0445
CAT'S MEOW, INC. D/B/A CAT'S MEOW, ET AL v. CITY OF
NEW ORLEANS (Parish of Orleans)
CALOGERO, C.J.
- not on panel; recused.
On the 20th
day of February, 1998 , the following
action was taken by the Supreme Court of Louisiana
in the case(s) listed below:
WRITS
GRANTED :
97-KK- 2456
STATE OF LOUISIANA v. SARAH HAVELY EDMONDSON (Parish
of Tangipahoa)
KIMBALL, J.
- not on panel.
97-K - 2802
STATE OF LOUISIANA v. FRANK H. COLEMAN, JR. (Parish
of Cameron)
KNOLL, J. -
not on panel; recused.
WRITS
GRANTED WITH ORDER :
97-C
- 2321 HELEN WITT, ET AL v. SUBARU OF AMERICA,
ET AL (Parish of Vernon)
See Per Curiam.
CALOGERO, C.J.
- dissents from the order and would deny the writ.
LEMMON, J.
- dissents from the order and would deny the writ.
KIMBALL, J.
- dissents from the order and would deny the wirt.
JOHNSON, J.
- not on panel.
97-C
- 2765 MICHAEL LABICHE v. LOUISIANA PATIENTS'
COMPENSATION FUND OVERSIGHT BOARD, ET AL (Parish of
East Baton Rouge)
See Per Curiam.
MARCUS, J.
- not on panel.
VICTORY, J.
- concurs.
TRAYLOR, J.
- concurs.
97-CC- 2992
BARBARA EVERETT, ON BEHALF OF HERSELF AND ALL OTHERS
SIMILARLY SITUATED VS. SOUTHERN TRANSPLANT SERVICE,
INC. ET AL C/W BARBARA MCFIELD RAE, INDIVIDUALLY AND
ON BEHALF OF HER MINOR CHILD, LEROY EVERETT, JR. VS.
SOUTHERN TRANSPLANT SERVICE, INC. ET AL (Parish of
Orleans)
VICTORY, J.
- not on panel.
98-CC- 0006
BOYD W. AITES v. STATE OF LOUISIANA, THROUGH THE DEPARTMENT
OF TRANSPORATION & DEVELOPMENT, ET AL (Parish
of Vernon)
KNOLL, J. -
not on panel.
98-CC- 0237
WILMETTA AMOS D/B/A WILSON'S TRUCKING COMPANY v. CX
TRANSPORTATION, A DIVISION OF TIC UNITED CORPORATION
(Parish of East Baton Rouge)
KIMBALL, J.
- not on panel.
98-KH- 0436
STATE EX REL ROBERT MYLES v. STATE OF LOUISIANA (Parish
of Orleans)
TRAYLOR, J.
- not on panel.
WRITS
GRANTED IN PART WITH ORDER / DENIED IN PART :
97-KH- 2093
STATE OF LOUISIANA v. WILFRED GRANT (Parish of Orleans)
MARCUS, J.
- would deny the writ.
KIMBALL, J.
- not on panel.
TRAYLOR, J.
- would deny the writ.
KNOLL, J. -
would deny the writ.
97-C - 3142
JOHNNY BOURQUE v. AUDUBON INSURANCE COMPANY (Parish
of St. Martin)
KIMBALL, J.
- not on panel.
INTERIM
SUSPENSION GRANTED; SEE ORDER:
97-B - 3157
IN RE: W. GLENN SOILEAU
KIMBALL, J.
- not on panel.
DISBARMENT
BY CONSENT ORDERED; SEE PER CURIAM:
97-B - 3219
IN RE: GEORGE A. GUIDRY, SR.
JOHNSON, J.
- not on panel.
REHEARINGS
DENIED :
97-CC- 2668
EDWARD SPUNIZO AND WIFE, NORMA SPUNIZO v. CHARITY
HOSPITAL IN NEW ORLEANS (Parish of Orleans)
VICTORY, J.
- not on panel.
TRAYLOR, J.
- would grant the rehearing.
97-CC- 2748
BRYAN K. PHILLIPS v. PATTERSON INSURANCE CO. ETAL
(Parish of Lafayette)
MARCUS, J.
- not on panel.
WRIT
NOT CONSIDERED :
98-KK- 0239
STATE OF LOUISIANA v. WHEELER SULLIVAN, ET AL. (Parish
of Orleans)
KNOLL, J. -
not on panel.
WRITS
DENIED :
96-KH- 1591
STATE EX REL GREGORY RUFFIN v. STATE OF LOUISIANA
(Parish of Orleans)
KIMBALL, J.
- not on panel.
96-KH- 2383
STATE OF LOUISIANA v. TYRONNE EDWARDS (Parish of Orleans)
CALOGERO, C.J.
- would grant the writ.
MARCUS, J.
- would grant the writ.
LEMMON, J.
- would grant the writ.
KIMBALL, J.
- not on panel.
97-KH- 0268
STATE EX REL HARRY BROWN v. STATE OF LOUISIANA (Parish
of Lafayette)
KIMBALL, J.
- not on panel.
97-CK- 0703
STATE OF LOUISIANA IN THE INTEREST OF K.H. (Parish
of East Baton Rouge)
LEMMON, J.
- would grant the writ.
KIMBALL, J.
- not on panel.
JOHNSON, J.
- would grant the writ.
97-KH- 1622
STATE EX REL AMEAL PARKER, JR. v. STATE OF LOUISIANA
(Parish of Orleans)
KNOLL, J. -
not on panel.
97-KH- 1835
STATE EX REL KENNETH RADFORD v. STATE OF LOUISIANA
(Parish of East Baton Rouge)
KNOLL, J. -
not on panel.
97-KH- 2051
STATE EX REL DAVID WILLIAMS v. STATE OF LOUISIANA
(Parish of East Baton Rouge)
CALOGERO, C.J.
- not on panel.
97-KH- 2077
STATE EX REL DONALD RAY JOHNSON v. STATE OF LOUISIANA
(Parish of East Feliciana)
KIMBALL, J.
- not on panel.
97-KH- 2078
STATE EX REL JOSEPH MARTIN, JR. v. STATE OF LOUISIANA
(Parish of Lafayette)
KNOLL, J. -
not on panel; recused.
97-KH- 2080
STATE EX REL FRED GRIFFEN v. STATE OF LOUISIANA (Parish
of DeSoto)
TRAYLOR, J.
- not on panel.
97-KH- 2082
STATE EX REL JAMES LANGENDORFER v. STATE OF LOUISIANA
(Parish of Caddo)
CALOGERO, C.J.
- not on panel.
97-KH- 2086
STATE EX REL HORACE PRICE v. STATE OF LOUISIANA (Parish
of Orleans)
VICTORY, J.
- not on panel
97-KH- 2096
STATE EX REL FRANCIS J. SERIGNY v. STATE OF LOUISIANA
(Parish of Lafourche)
CALOGERO, C.J.
- not on panel.
97-KH- 2097
STATE EX REL LARRY VALENTINE v. STATE OF LOUISIANA
(Parish of Orleans)
MARCUS, J.
- not on panel.
97-KH- 2105
STATE EX REL LARONE WILLIAMS, JR. v. STATE OF LOUISIANA
(Parish of Beauregard)
CALOGERO, C.J.
- not on panel.
97-KH- 2106
STATE EX REL ROBERT S. TOOMER v. STATE OF LOUISIANA
(Parish of Washington)
MARCUS, J.
- not on panel.
97-KH- 2111
STATE OF LOUISIANA v. SIDNEY MOSES (Parish of Orleans)
TRAYLOR, J.
- not on panel.
97-KH- 2116
STATE EX REL ANTHONY CARTER v. STATE OF LOUISIANA
(Parish of Orleans)
LEMMON, J.
- not on panel.
97-KH- 2122
STATE EX REL BRETT BURGER v. STATE OF LOUISIANA (Parish
of Orleans)
KIMBALL, J.
- not on panel.
97-KH- 2123
STATE OF LOUISIANA v. RODNEY WILLIAMS (Parish of Orleans)
VICTORY, J.
- not on panel.
97-KH- 2126
STATE EX REL EARL BULLOCK v. STATE OF LOUISIANA (Parish
of Orleans)
LEMMON, J.
- not on panel.
97-K - 2626
STATE OF LOUISIANA v. WAYNE AMATO (Parish of East
Baton Rouge)
CALOGERO, C.J.
- would grant the writ.
MARCUS, J.
- would grant the writ.
VICTORY, J.
- not on panel.
97-K - 2644
STATE OF LOUISIANA v. WAYNE AMATO (Parish of East
Baton Rouge)
VICTORY, J.
- not on panel.
TRAYLOR, J.
- would grant the writ.
97-KO- 2735
STATE OF LOUISIANA v. EUGENE FORREST (Parish of Orleans)
TRAYLOR, J.
- not on panel.
97-OK- 2751
STATE OF LOUISIANA v. GERALD A. WARD (Parish of Vernon)
TRAYLOR, J.
- not on panel.
97-K - 2761
STATE OF LOUISIANA v. JUVONTE LAMARK TURNER (Parish
of Vernon)
VICTORY, J.
- not on panel.
97-K - 2799
STATE OF LOUISIANA v. TOM DEVILLE (Parish of Lafayette)
MARCUS, J.
- not on panel.
VICTORY, J.
- would grant the writ.
TRAYLOR, J.
- would grant the writ.
KNOLL, J. -
would grant the writ.
97-KH- 2853
STATE EX REL RONALD GLOVER v. STATE OF LOUISIANA (Parish
of East Baton Rouge)
VICTORY, J.
- not on panel.
97-CC- 2903
RUDOLPH WILLIAMS AND MARGARET WILLIAMS, ON BEHALF
OF THEMSELVES AND THEIR MINOR SON, NICHOLAS TROY WILLIAMS
v. OCHSNER CLINIC, A PROFESSIONAL CORPORATION, AND
DR. NAGLAA A. SHOURBAJI (Parish of Orleans)
MARCUS, J.
- not on panel.
KIMBALL, J.
- would grant the writ.
VICTORY, J.
- would grant the writ.
TRAYLOR, J.
- would grant the writ.
97-C - 2994
ARCH-AIR FREIGHT, INC., ET AL v. JAMES D. WILSON,
ET AL (Parish of Jefferson)
KIMBALL, J.
- not on panel.
97-CC- 3031
KEITH S. MORGAN AND BARBARA B. MORGAN v. THE EARNEST
CORPORATION AND BEAU CHENE HOMEOWNERS ASSOCIATION,
INC. C/W CECILIA H. BEST, WIFE OF/AND JAMES P. BEST
v. BEAU CHENE HOMEOWNERS ASSOCIATION, INC., THE EARNEST
CORPORATION, MORGAN EARNEST, BARRY RIPPLE, WALDEMAR
S. NELSON & CO., INC., AND THE LOUISIANA DEPARTMENT
OF TRANSPORTATION AND DEVELOPMENT (Parish of St. Tammany)
LEMMON, J.
- would grant the writ.
KNOLL, J. -
not on panel.
97-C - 3089
CLASSIC IMPORTS, INC., ET AL v. MICHAEL J. SINGLETON,
ET AL (Parish of Orleans)
MARCUS, J.
- not on panel.
97-C - 3112
CLASSIC IMPORTS, INC. ET AL v. MICHAEL J. SINGLETON,
ET AL (Parish of Orleans)
MARCUS, J.
- not on panel.
KNOLL, J. -
would grant the writ.
97-CC- 3139
VERONICA HUNTER v. RHONDA MAGEE ROBERTSON (Parish
of Orleans)
MARCUS, J.
- not on panel.
LEMMON, J.
- would grant the writ.
TRAYLOR, J.
- would grant the writ.
97-C - 3141
VICARI CONTRACTORS, INC. v. PARISH OF JEFFERSON (Parish
of Jefferson)
LEMMON, J.
- not on panel.
97-C - 3143
WILBUR MARVIN AND WALKER, LA., COMMERCIAL PROPERTIES
DEVELOPMENT COMPANY, L.L.C. v. HIBERNIA NATIONAL BANK
(Parish of East Baton Rouge)
JOHNSON, J.
- not on panel.
97-CC- 3146
ALVENIS CORTES, ET AL v. STATE FARM MUTUAL AUTOMOBILE
INSURANCE COMPANY, ET AL (Parish of St. Tammany)
MARCUS, J.
- not on panel.
97-C - 3148
PROPERTY PLUS, INC. D/B/A PRUDENTIAL LOUISIANA PROPERTIES
v. MANAGEMENT & RENTALS, INC. AND JOHN T. SCURLOCK
(Parish of Jefferson)
CALOGERO, C.J.
- not on panel.
97-CC- 3151
TOMMY RICHARDSON AND JACQUELINE RICHARDSON v. LESTER
J. SETTOON, ABC INSURANCE COMPANY, PONCHATOULA VOLUNTEER
FIRE DEPARTMENT, AND CIGNA INSURANCE COMPANY (Parish
of Tangipahoa)
MARCUS, J.
- would grant the writ.
VICTORY, J.
- would grant the writ.
KNOLL, J. -
not on panel.
97-CC- 3152
SANDRA GLOVER v. SHIFFLET TRANSPORT SERVICES, INC.
ET AL (Parish of Orleans)
CALOGERO, C.J.
- would grant the writ.
VICTORY, J.
- not on panel.
97-CC- 3153
KEITH EVANS v. ORLEANS PARISH SCHOOL BOARD
(Office of
Workers' Compensation District # 8)
JOHNSON, J.
- not on panel.
97-CC- 3155
VADA ARMSTRONG, ON BEHALF OF D.A. & D.A. v. MISSOURI
PACIFIC RAILROAD COMPANY, ET AL (Parish of Ouachita)
TRAYLOR, J.
- not on panel.
97-C - 3156
FLOYE McENERY SMITH, ET AL v. DONALD M. HUGHES, ET
AL (Parish of Richland)
CALOGERO, C.J.
- not on panel.
97-CC- 3166
BARRY B. KATZ D/B/A BUENA VISTA REAL ESTATE v. POYDRAS
INVESTMENTS, INC. AND WARREN VALENTINO (Parish of
Orleans)
CALOGERO, C.J.
- not on panel.
97-CC- 3168
DAVE HAAS EWELL, JR., ET AL v. PETRO PROCESSORS OF
LOUISIANA, INC., ET AL (Parish of East Baton Rouge)
MARCUS, J.
- not on panel.
97-C - 3172
CONNIE POWELL SMITH v. TYRONE SMITH (Parish of Orleans)
KIMBALL, J.
- not on panel.
97-CJ- 3173
STATE OF LOUISIANA IN THE INTEREST OF B. K. F. (Parish
of Jefferson)
VICTORY, J.
- not on panel.
97-C - 3189
ANNA WARFIELD v. JOSEPH R. MCMAHON AND FIRST FINANCIAL
INSURANCE COMPANY (Parish of Orleans)
JOHNSON, J.
- not on panel.
TRAYLOR, J.
- would grant the writ.
97-C - 3192
INTERDICTION OF DUVAL CANTU (Parish of Jefferson)
MARCUS, J.
- not on panel.
97-C - 3195
LARRY J. MORGAN v. NEW ORLEANS PUBLIC FACILITY MANAGEMENT,
INC. (Parish of Orleans)
KIMBALL, J.
- not on panel.
JOHNSON, J.
- would grant the writ.
97-CC- 3196
GLEN EZERNACK, ET AL v. SABINE PARISH SCHOOL BOARD,
ET AL (Parish of Sabine)
JOHNSON, J.
- not on panel.
97-KK- 3198
STATE OF LOUISIANA v. LEO WIGGINS, JR. (Parish of
Avoyelles)
KNOLL, J. -
not on panel; recused.
97-CC- 3201
JOHN M. COMPTON, SR. v. CLEVELAND M. BARNES, AUTOMOTIVE
CASUALTY INSURANCE COMPANY, COLONIAL LLOYD'S, J. EDWARD
LAYRISSON, TANGIPAHOA PARISH SHERIFF, KERMIT STEWART,
DAVID SCHAERER, AND THE LOUISIANA SHERIFF'S RISK PROGRAM/HUNT
INSURANCE GROUP, INC. (Parish of Tangipahoa)
CALOGERO, C.J.
- not on panel.
TRAYLOR, J.
- would grant the writ.
97-C - 3203
VIRGINIA COLLINS v. DANIEL GERSTNER AND RONALD LIUZZA
C/W VIRGINIA COLLINS v. ELMWOOD VILLAGE CENTER, et
al (Parish of Jefferson)
LEMMON, J.
- not on panel.
97-C - 3205
BRENDA J. DIXON-GHOLAR v. E-Z SERVE MAJIK MARKET (Office
of Workers' Compensation District # 8)
KIMBALL, J.
- not on panel.
TRAYLOR, J.
- would grant the writ.
97-C - 3206
SOUTHERN SIDING COMPANY, INC. v. MR. AND MRS. PAUL
RAYMOND (Parish of East Baton Rouge)
JOHNSON, J.
- not on panel.
KNOLL, J. -
would grant the writ.
97-C - 3207
DAVID W. MILLET, SR. v. BETTIE J. LOYD CRUMP (Parish
of St. John Baptist)
TRAYLOR, J.
- not on panel.
97-C - 3208
SUCCESSION OF GEORGE K. PRATT, IV (Parish of Jefferson)
MARCUS, J.
- not on panel.
97-CC- 3215
BERNICE G. MORVANT, WIFE OF AND NORRIS J. MORVANT
v. DR. WAYNE PHARO, GEORGE J. WHITMAN AND THE TRAVELERS
INSURANCE COMPANY (Parish of Lafourche)
VICTORY, J.
- not on panel.
97-C - 3216
JAMES DAVID SCHMIDT v. WAL-MART STORES, INC., ET AL
(Parish of Orleans)
JOHNSON, J.
- not on panel.
VICTORY, J.
- would grant the writ.
97-C - 3218
MORTGAGE PROPERTIES CORPORATION v. TCB, INC. ET AL
C/W TCB, INC. v. FIRST BOSTON MORTGAGE CAPITAL CORPORATION
AND GE CAPITAL ASSET MANAGEMENT CORPORATION (Parish
of Jefferson)
TRAYLOR, J.
- not on panel.
98-C - 0001
CAPTAIN D. RAMON MELON v. CRESCENT SHIP SERVICE, INC.
AND CERTAIN UNDERWRITERS AT LLOYD'S LONDON (Parish
of Ascension)
JOHNSON, J.
- not on panel.
98-KK- 0002
STATE OF LOUISIANA v. HENRY AND LARNELL SAUVIAC (Parish
of Jefferson)
LEMMON, J.
- not on panel.
98-KK- 0008
STATE OF LOUISIANA v. RICKEY CEASAR (Parish of Orleans)
MARCUS, J.
- not on panel.
TRAYLOR, J.
- would grant the writ.
KNOLL, J. -
would grant the writ.
98-CC- 0009
DON MILLER, ET AL. v. CONTINENTAL INSURANCE, ET AL.
(Parish of East Baton Rouge)
CALOGERO, C.J.
- not on panel.
98-C - 0010
MELVIN HAMILTON, SR. v. LAYMON GODWIN AS SHERIFF OF
THE OUACHITA PARISH SHERIFF'S OFFICE (Parish of Ouachita)
VICTORY, J.
- not on panel.
98-C - 0011
WALTER LEMAIRE v. ESTATE OF ROBERT L. HARRINGTON,
JR., ET AL (Parish of Vermilion)
LEMMON, J.
- not on panel.
VICTORY, J.
- would grant the writ.
98-CC- 0013
LODA CURRY, ET AL v. JAMIE BORRERO, M.D. (Parish of
Rapides)
TRAYLOR, J.
- not on panel.
98-C - 0022
JOAN M. PERRIN v. KENNETH S. KUEHNE, HELEN ADELE KUEHNE
EVANS, RONALD C. KUEHNE, MARY ANN KUEHNE COMARDA,
DIANE KUEHNE GUIDRY, KAREN KUEHNE HARRISON, EUGENE
L. KUEHNE, JR., MICHAEL S. KUEHNE, KIM KUEHNE BREAUX,
HARRIET KUEHNE FRY, PRISCILLA MARY KUEHNE HEINZ, CHRISTOPHER
M. KUEHNE, PAUL KENT KUEHNE, TIMOTHY JOHN KUEHNE,
DAVID E. CARTER AND DAVID E. CARTER EXTERMINATING
COMPANY, INC. (Parish of Jefferson)
VICTORY, J.
- not on panel.
98-KH- 0046
STATE EX REL ROY LEE MAYS v. STATE OF LOUISIANA (Parish
of Lincoln)
VICTORY, J.
- not on panel.
98-KH- 0152
STATE EX REL WESLEY DYSON, ET AL v. STATE OF LOUISIANA
(Parish of East Baton Rouge)
MARCUS, J.
- not on panel.
98-CC- 0172
730 BIENVILLE PARTNERS, INC. v. AUBREY R. SEILER,
MILTON W. SEILER, WILLIAM G. SEILER, ETHEL S. FITZSIMMONS,
MADELYN S. LOOMIS, SUZANNE S. GUIDRY, STEPHEN P. SEILER,
EDWARD H. SEILER, SR., INC., LEISURE PURSUITS, INC.
AND AMERICAN RESTAURANT, INC. (Parish of Orleans)
CALOGERO, C.J.
- not on panel.
98-KH- 0319
STATE EX REL AMEAL PARKER, JR. v. STATE OF LOUISIANA
(Parish of Orleans)
LEMMON, J.
- not on panel.