FOR IMMEDIATE
NEWS RELEASE
NEWS RELEASE
# 69
FROM: CLERK
OF SUPREME COURT OF LOUISIANA
The Opinion
handed down on the 5th day of September,
2001 , is as follows:
BY
CALOGERO, C.J. :
2000-C-
3518 ELEVATING BOATS, INC. v. PARISH OF ST. BERNARD,
ET AL. (Parish of St. Bernard)
For the foregoing
reasons, we reverse the court of appeal's judgment
and reinstate the district court's judgment that the
sales and use tax obligations of Elevating Boats,
Inc. to St. Bernard Parish, including an annual interest
penalty, is not prescribed. We further reverse the
court of appeal's judgment and reinstate the district
court's judgment that Elevating Boats is a retailer
for occupational license tax purposes; however, we
find that the occupational license taxes prior to
1991 are prescribed. Finally, we find that an inter-parish
credit is not due Elevating Boats, Inc. This matter
is remanded to the district court with instructions
to enter a judgment in favor of Elevating Boats, Inc.
against the Parish of St. Bernard for the difference
between the $1,956,805.00 paid under protest and the
past due taxes owed including 15% annual interest
penalty. Finally, the district court should allocate
the costs of these proceedings equally between the
parties.
COURT OF APPEAL
JUDGMENT REVERSED; DISTRICT COURT JUDGMENT REINSTATED
IN PART; CASE REMANDED TO THE DISTRICT COURT.
Retired Judge
Robert L. Lobrano, assigned as Justice Pro Tempore,
sitting for Associate Justice Harry T. Lemmon; Judge
Felicia Toney Williams, of the Second Circuit Court
of Appeal, assigned as Justice Pro Tempore, sitting
for Associate Justice Bernette J. Johnson.
VICTORY,
J., dissents in part and assigns reasons .